Monday, January 31, 2011

MAC Prep + Prime Transparent Finishing Powder Controversy?

Well hello, long time no talk! Things have been a bit hectic for me over the holiday season, and I just started a new, very time consuming job- which is a great challenge for me, but super exciting! And, I hate to say it, but sometimes I just need a bit of a break from the internets!

Photobucket

Never fear though, because I'm back, and with a review of MAC's Prep+Prime Transparent Finishing Powder. This powder is kinda MAC's version of MUFE's HD powder, but certainly with a twist. Is it better or worse? Keep reading to find out!

PS: There is quite a surprise to be had!


First, allow me to draw your attention to this vid by GossMakeupArtist, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fM4foAf1tHc, who addresses the recent celebrities who have been photographed with white powder on their face. His verdict? Makeup Forever's HD powder is the culprit!

It was also in this video that I first was intrigued by MAC's Prep+Prime Transparent Finishing Powder, because he said that he tested this powder as well, and found that it did not create the same white effect. So, on a recent trip to MAC, as I was purchasing the Pro-Longwear foundation, I decided to also pick up this sheer finishing powder.

Photobucket

I have been wearing it for a week, and have, quite simply, liked it. It keeps my makeup from wearing off, and goes well with the Pro Longwear foundation (which as the name suggests, is also longlasting). I also liked the feather-light feel and finish- it does not look cakey or make me feel overdone.

Photobucket
unblended 


So, all was well...until today! I obviously wanted to share this product with you lovely folks, and so as I was photographing the product, I noticed some very disconcerting things:

When I took photos without a flash, it looked great....

PhotobucketPhotobucket
No Flash/ Flash

...However, when I used a flash, I got the white face/tan body look! This is a deal-breaker for any foundation or powder- doesn't matter how great it makes me look in person, if I can't be photographed and look human, then I don't want it! I don't want to have to hide any time someone pulls out the camera!!

I then took a photo of this powder blended into my skin, first with a flash, then without.
Photobucket Photobucket
l: this blended in, invisible to the naked eye!!          r: no flash, you cannot see the white powder.

You will notice that with a flash, the white powder is visible, even though it is completely invisible without the flash. This is exactly what Goss showed with MUFE's powder, and here it is occurring with MAC's.

Needless to say, I am kinda VERY disappointed with this product. I got my hopes up that maybe I'd found the perfect skin routine, only to have those hopes squashed with my newest findings. Now, I am not saying that this is ALL the powder's fault- it seems to me a combination of the powder and foundation- but, due to the photos I took with the powder alone, it appears that it plays a significant role.

Verdict: Gorgeous application for day-to-day use, but you'll get caught looking like a ghost in flash photography!!

4 comments:

JC said...

try the Laura Mercier translucent powder. it's the only true translucent powder on the market (or was, several years ago)

Katie said...

I have the MUFE HD and I actually like it a lot. Then again.... I'm very, VERY white so it blends well for me, haha.

Jacquelyn said...

I have this product and what I don't like about it is that when I took a pic of myself wearning ths powder on my face, I looked ashy and it was terrible! I have hot touched it since then.

GoriNiqabiWife said...

I just had the same problem when a photo was taken of me. I started using the mac sculpt foundation and also this mac prep and prime powder. I had really awful flash back and my face looked like a white mask. I couldn't figure out if it was the foundation or the powder! So I did research online today and thanks to your post and the photos you posted, I realized it's definitely the powder! Thanks so much for posting this. It solved the mystery for me. Have you found another translucent powder yet that doesn't cause this effect? I've used makeup forever HD as you mentioned and never had this flash back problem. Can you do a test of it?